Crust-Lover’s Layered Apple Pie

Crust-Lover's Layered Apple Pie - offbeat + inspired

Apple pie. It’s in a league of its own. And for such a highly revered dessert, it’s very forgiving. There are thousands of recipes and renditions of “traditional” apple pie being celebrated all over the country. From the type of crust, to the variety and cut of the apples, to the spices and toppings — apple pie lends itself generously to adaptation.

Crust-Lover's Layered Apple Pie - offbeat + inspired

I’ve always enjoyed this dessert simply because it heralds the coming of fall. And as if a buttery, flaky crust filled to the brim with ripe, cinnamon apples wasn’t enough — the smell! When an apple pie is baking, everything, and I mean everything…is right with the world.

But I have a confession. When there’s a steaming slice of apple pie on a plate in front of me, there’s only one thing going through my mind: do I save the crust for last and power through the filling, or do I go straight for the crust, scoop up some of the filling for a perfect crust/apple ratio and toss the leftover mush? I know…terrible.

Crust-Lover's Layered Apple Pie - offbeat + inspired

This dilemma has had me tweaking apple pie recipes for years. I’ve sliced the apples thinner, dried them before baking, topped them with crumble instead of a second crust to let more moisture escape during the bake — the list goes on. The thinly sliced apples definitely improved things, and minimizing the amount of butter and sugar I added to the filling kept the goop-factor fairly low — but there was still something missing. I wanted that golden, savory crust all throughout the pie. I wanted every single bite to have that flaky, toasty layer just like the prized edges I always saved for last. I also didn’t want to keep compromising the filling. I wanted sweet, tart apples cloaked in a rich, smoothly spiced sauce — and I wanted that marvelous blend to exist in a thin layer between beautifully golden crusts. Multiply that delightful little combo by three, and you get what I’m calling the Crust Lover’s Layered Apple Pie. You could also call it Lasagna-Style Apple Pie — if you’re able to shake the image of tomato sauce mixing with apples and pie crust.

Crust-Lover's Layered Apple Pie - offbeat + inspired

This pie has 3 crusts and 3 thin layers apple filling. It’s literally everything I dreamed it would be. I topped it with a scoop of homemade spiced vanilla whipped cream — and it was incredible.

This is my new go-to apple pie recipe. I hope you give it a try and enjoy it as much as I did!

Crust-Lover's Layered Apple Pie - offbeat + inspired

Do I have any fellow crust enthusiasts out there? Anyone suffering from the same filling-overload-dilemma? I would love to hear about all of your apple pie woes and delights! Please share in the comments at the bottom!

Crust-Lover's Layered Apple Pie - offbeat + inspired

The Handcarved Acacia Cake Stand can be found at Anthropologie, here! The Latte Bowl can also be found at Anthro, here!

Crust-Lover's Layered Apple Pie - offbeat + inspired

Crust-Lover's Layered Apple Pie - offbeat + inspired

Crust-Lover's Layered Apple Pie - offbeat + inspired

Crust-Lover's Layered Apple Pie - offbeat + inspired

Crust-Lover's Layered Apple Pie - offbeat + inspired

Crust-Lover's Layered Apple Pie - offbeat + inspired

Crust-Lover's Layered Apple Pie - offbeat + inspired

Crust-Lover's Layered Apple Pie - offbeat + inspired

Crust-Lover's Layered Apple Pie - offbeat + inspired

Crust-Lover's Layered Apple Pie - offbeat + inspired

Where to buy…

the Handcarved Acacia Cake Stand (small) / Anthropologie
the white Latte Bowl / Anthropologie
the Emile Henry Artisan Ruffled Pie Dish / Williams Sonoma
the Red Railroad Stripe Napkin / Ortolan Organic

Crust-Lover’s Layered Apple Pie

For the Crust

75g, or a scant 2/3 cup rye flour
175g or 1 1/2 cups unbleached all-purpose flour
1/4 teaspoon fine grain sea salt
8 oz. or 1 cup salted butter
1/3 cup or 80 ml cold water

I used Heidi Swanson‘s Flaky Rye Pie Crust recipe, as shared on the Herriott Grace blog here.

Follow this method for making the crust. It yields such a beautiful flake, and the dough is a dream to work with.

For the Filling

5 medium sweet-tart apples (I used Braeburns)
1/4 cup granulated sugar
1 1/2 tbsp. ground cinnamon
1/2 tsp. nutmeg
1/2 tsp. ground ginger
1/4 tsp. ground clove
6 tbsp. salted butter, chilled and cubed

For the Whipped Cream

1 cup heavy whipping cream
2 tbsp. powdered sugar
1 tsp. vanilla bean paste (or vanilla extract)
1 tsp. ground cinnamon
1 tsp. ground cardamom

First, make the crust! Follow this method.

While the dough is chilling, preheat your oven to 350 degrees F and butter your pie plate.

Remove one of the chilled discs of dough from the fridge and divide it in 2 equal parts. Roll them out on a lightly floured surface into two rounds that will fit inside your pie plate. These will be your internal crust layers.

Place them on a parchment lined baking sheet and bake for 15-20 minutes until lightl golden and puffy.

While the internal crusts are cooling, adjust your oven temperature to 475 degrees F.

Core, peel and thinly slice your apples (I use this nifty little gadget to do it all at once), put them in a large bowl and add the sugar and spices. Stir with a wooden spoon or toss with your hands until the apples are evenly coated.

Remove the remaining disc of chilled dough from the refrigerator and roll it out on a lightly floured surface. Keep it as round as you can!

Transfer the dough to your pie plate and trim the edges, leaving about 1/2 inch of overhang that you can fold under and press to make a perfectly smooth edge.

Spread a layer of apples, about 1/2-3/4-inch thick, on the bottom of the pie crust. Dot this layer with 2 tbsp. of cubed butter, and top with one of your pre-baked crust rounds. Repeat this for the next 2 layers. The very top layer will be apples dotted with the last 2 tbsp. of cubed butter. Make sure you use enough apples on that top layer to hide the crust layer beneath it.

Place your pie on a rack positioned in the bottom third of the oven and bake for about 35-40 minutes. Start checking the pie around the 25 minute mark to make sure the crust and apples aren’t browning too quickly.

When the pie is done, remove it from the oven and let it cool for at least 15 minutes before serving.

While the pie is cooling, make the whipped cream. Combine the cream, sugar, vanilla and spices in a medium bowl and beat with a hand mixer on high for about 2-3 minutes until the cream thickens enough to hold its shape. Refrigerate until you’re ready to use it. I suggest adding a healthy scoop to each slice of pie as you serve them.

If you try this recipe and take a picture of it, please share it on Instagram or Steller and tag me @tifforelie so I can see! I would love to know how it turned out for you! Find me on IG here, and on Steller here!


Douglas Fir Spring Tip Whipped Sweet Butter

Douglas Fir Spring Tip Whipped Sweet Butter - offbeat + inspired

Kristan Raines (of The Broken Bread) and I recently teamed up to create a few recipes infused with wildcrafted tea from Juniper Ridge. I’m so excited to be collaborating with this girl. She is incredibly talented, sweet as can be, and her recipes and food photography are hypnotizing. If you haven’t already checked out her work or followed her on Instagram, you must!

Keep reading!

Lavender-Honey Iced Latte

Lavender-Honey Iced Latte - offbeat + inspired-7

I’m a little obsessed with making flavor infused simple syrups (as evidenced by the excessive number of my recipes that include them in some form). The flavor combinations are endless and, in my opinion, it’s one of the easiest and most fun ways to add variety to drinks like iced tea, lemonade, cocktails and of course, coffee.

Keep reading!

Cookbooking: Joy The Baker | Chocolate Bourbon-Spiked Banana Bread

Cookbooking: Joy The Baker | Chocolate Bourbon-Spiked Banana Bread - offbeat + inspired

For the longest time, I didn’t consider myself much of a baker – the idea of having to measure turned me off. I generally have more of a “let’s throw in a little of this and a little of that until it tastes good” mentality.

Enter Joy The Baker. Joy has been sharing her kitchen creations for a while, but I just started following her regularly several months ago (what the heck was I waiting for?). Her witty, endearing writing makes you feel like you’re chatting over a cup of coffee and a plate of Peanut Butter Bacon Pancakes, while her recipes have the power to induce spontaneous salivation. Coffee Bacon Sandwiches will be happening very soon in my kitchen, and Dark Chocolate, Pistachio + Smoked Sea Salt Cookies inspired my own cupcake version.

Keep reading!

Mango Two Ways [and a giveaway with Whole Foods!]

Mango 2 ways main image 3

Happy Monday! Tiffany and I are so excited about today’s post! We’ve teamed up with Whole Foods to bring you two delicious mango recipes – one savory, one sweet.

Mango has quickly become one of my favorite warm weather ingredients. It’s incredibly versatile and works well in everything from smoothies to cocktails to the recipes we’re sharing today. Nothing says summer like the flavor of mango – and Mango + Shrimp Skewers and Mango, Rosemary + Ginger Shortbread Cookies are the perfect way to kick off the season.

Keep reading!

DIY Citrus Salt Scrub

DIY Citrus Salt Scrub - offbeat + inspired

I am obsessed with all things citrus. Whether it’s as simple as putting a slice of lime in my water or involves a decadent lemon-basil coffee cake (recipe for that coming soon!), I am officially smitten. My most recent citrus creation is this super easy sea salt scrub. Homemade scrubs take about 5 minutes to make (sometimes even less) and they’re not littered with harsh chemicals or additives found in many store-bought versions. They also make great gifts – although you may want to make two batches so you can keep one for yourself.

Keep reading!

Coffee-Maple Candied Bacon

Coffee-Maple Candied Bacon - offbeat + inspired-5

What’s better than bacon? Candied bacon with rich, earthy flavors of coffee, sweet maple syrup, caramelized sugar and spicy black pepper.

This recipe is dangerously easy to make, with only a few ingredients: bacon, freshly roasted coffee (I like using a full-bodied, dark roast such as FreshGround’s Sumatra Aceh), sugar, maple syrup and a touch of black pepper. Word of advice? Make this in small batches – or at least have friends over to share the results with. Otherwise before you know it, you’ll have consumed a shameful amount of bacon all by yourself. (Yup, I’m speaking from personal experience.)

Keep reading!

Spiced Bourbon Coffee

Spiced Bourbon Coffee - offbeat + inspired-6

“Winter is the time for comfort, for good food and warmth, for the touch of a friendly hand and for a talk beside the fire: it is the time for home.” 
-Edith Sitwell

In the fall when temperatures start to drop, I find myself looking forward to winter. There’s something romantic, serene and comforting about the season that forces me into hibernation. Outdoor activities give way to quiet evenings at home, and lively summer barbecues turn to intimate dinners. The first few snowfalls cover everything with a brilliant white blanket, and holiday festivities help me avoid the impending cabin fever.

Eventually, the enjoyment of winter fades away and is replaced by an eager anticipation of spring. It’s this time of year that I’m weary of the cold. The occasional sunlight teases as it warms me through my kitchen window – spring must be coming! And then I walk outside, only to turn back in my house to don a few more layers of clothing.

When everything in me craves the warmer season to come, it’s easy to forget the joys of winter. This year, however, I’m trying to be more intentional, taking advantage of what this season has to offer. Spring will come. But meanwhile, there’s still time for admiring snow-laden trees, bundling up under a cozy blanket and quietly sipping on Spiced Bourbon Coffee by the fire.

Keep reading!

Banana-Rum Scones

Banana-Rum Scones - offbeat + inspired-5

Years ago over one of my winter breaks in college, my mom and I spent a week together in New Hampshire. While some of my friends traveled to warmer climates, I opted for snowy mountains. I had the chance to snowboard, my mom and I snowshoed and we soaked in the beauty of the outdoors. To top it all off, we made sure to enjoy incredible food.

While wandering around the local area, we came across a quaint little bakery selling freshly baked muffins, scones and other pastries. The scones they had there remain the best ones I have ever tasted in my life. Maybe it was the beautiful evergreen trees layered with sparkling flakes and the blanket of crunching snow under my feet that made a warm scone and a cup of coffee taste so amazing. Or maybe those flaky, buttery treats were special because they were a culinary discovery I shared with my mom. Whatever it was, that experience turned me into a scone lover.

Keep reading!

Clean Eating | Broiled Grapefruit with Yogurt + Cinnamon

Broiled Grapefruit with Yogurt + Cinnamon - offbeat + inspired-9

I don’t mind the cold and snow during the beginning of winter, but around this time of year I start to get antsy. My love for cuddling up with comfort food in front of the fireplace gives way to a desire to eat on a restaurant patio, run along the riverfront path or head over to the neighbor’s for drinks and laughs around their fire pit.

Keep reading!